Be happy and stay the course!
Tuesday, April 25th, 2006Exercise physiology is a profession that is evolving, just as nursing is a profession that continues to experience constant change. Most students interested in exercise physiology do not major in it. For many reasons, they nonetheless often call themselves exercise physiologists. Of course, this is wrong but such divergent views about exercise science and exercise physiology exist today that no one is really wanting to tackle them. Students don’t know any different. After all, they depend on the teachers for guidance. The teachers contribution to the exercise physiology versus sports medicine dialogue is essentially zero. In short, they are not interested in a solution to the students’ problems.
Helping students to get the big picture is not easy. A few students are able to handle the discussion. Some feel strongly the need to argue or even demonstrate disrespect when exercise science (as an example) is defined for what it actually is. Others are somewhat less aggressive, but cautious about believing something different from sports medicine. Still others just do not care. So, how do you help students like these? That is the question!
I believe it is difficult. At times, it is impossible and a waste of time to continue trying to change the thinking of students who are not interested. Honestly, you cannot make a dog or a horse drink water if either is not interested. The same is true for students. But, the risk of students not knowing often drives the college teacher to keep trying.
I can tell you from personal experience that it is a complete waste of time. Students who are not interested are disruptive and problematic. Having said that, what do you do? I think one answer is to continue writing as I have done. Continue sharing what matters, just as I am doing in this post.
History matters. What I have to say matters. None of it is a waste of time even should a student not get it. The future of exercise physiology depends on boldness and courage to stay the course. It is not uncommon that these things happen when change is introduced that results in a certain uncomfortableness among students and colleagues.
Exercise physiology is a healthcare profession. It is not or does not have to be a discipline limited to research and/or cardiac rehab or even to just athletics. In regards to rehab, it is sad to acknowledge that fact that what was a primary area of significant work for exercise physiologists no longer is as it was. Cardiac rehab is essentially a nursing and/or hospital model of operation (phases I and II vs. what was and still is important, phase III).
Nurses study and learn from their past. We do not. History is important, but we do not think in those terms. Historically speaking, exercise physiologists have always associated with sports medicine. But, sports medicine is not exercise physiology. Since only a few brave souls have come together to fight for the rights of exercise physiologists to exist within their own professional organization, the economic and otherwise rewards have been slow in coming.
Time after time, it has been declared that “nurses must unite” to access professional autonomy and self-determination. And, yet after 100+ years, they are still as divided as ever. They spend so much time fighting each other that they often have little time fighting their true enemies. Frankly, this is exactly what exercise phyiologists are doing?
Nurses should be (and have learned to some extent) to work together. The ASEP leaders have urged exercise physiologists to work together for nearly a decade now. With a unified front, exercise physiologists could accomplish so many important things to help everyone that it is, unfortunately, a very sad fact that progress is so slow. Students and exercise physiologists, like nurses, must become active in building their profession. Do not undervalue your position as a student. You can make a difference. Do you really want to work side-by-side with high school graduates in fitness jobs at $7/hr without any hope of medical benefits? Of course not. A college education means something in this country or, at least, it is should.
Point in fact, however, a degree in exercise science is meaningless. But, a degree in exercise physiology gives hope of something better. Just as nursing for a long time was a trade. Perhaps, the nurse functioned as a widow who had nursed her husband till his diemise. My point is that almost anyone in the beginning could call herself a nurse, just anyone can today call him- or herself an exercise physiologist.
In other words, are these exercise science graduates really exercise physiologists? Not to the leaders of the American Society of Exercise Physiologists, but to the public and others they are. This is most unfortunate. What is the real image of exercise physiologists? They are members of the ASEP organization, graduates of an accredited exercise physiology degree program, board certified exercise physiologist, uphold the ASEP code of ethics, and understand the exercise physiologists’ standards of professional practice.
Just as nursing was so poorly understood for many decades, it is the same with exercise physiology. This is changing, however, as it has with nursing. “Nursing is doctoring…” is now very similar to the idea that “exercise physiology is a healthcare profession.”
Just as prior to 1873 the trained nurse did not exist in this country, prior to 1997 the professional infrastructure did not exist as a credible foundation from which to promote and develop exercise physiology as a healthcare profession. In light of what has transpired since then, we should be happy with our work.